At some point many growing stores need something no app quite does. Maybe it is a pricing rule, a data sync, or an admin tool shaped around your process. That is when a Shopify custom app becomes an option worth considering, alongside public App Store apps and external automations. This guide explains the differences, what a custom app can and cannot do, what upkeep it needs, and how to brief a developer so you get the right thing built.
Three ways to add functionality
Public apps
Public apps are listed in the Shopify App Store and built for many merchants. They are quick to install, maintained by the vendor, and often cheap compared with building. The trade-off is fit: they solve the common version of a problem, and you depend on the vendor’s roadmap and pricing.
Custom apps
A Shopify custom app is built for one store (or one organization). It can be created directly in the store admin for simple API access, or built by a developer through Shopify’s Partner tools for richer features such as embedded admin screens. It does what you need and nothing else, but you own its maintenance.
External automation
Sometimes you do not need an app at all. A workflow in Shopify Flow or a tool like n8n, listening to webhooks and calling the Admin API, can handle syncing, tagging, routing and notifications without a user interface inside Shopify.
| Factor | Public app | Custom app | External automation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Time to start | Fastest | Slowest | Fast to moderate |
| Fit to your process | Generic | Exact | Good for data flows |
| Admin interface | Provided | Can be built | Usually none |
| Maintenance | Vendor | You or your partner | You or your partner |
| Best for | Common needs | Unique needs core to the business | Moving data between systems |
What a Shopify custom app can do
Custom apps work through Shopify’s APIs and extension points. In general terms they can:
- Read and write store data through the Admin API, such as products, orders, customers, inventory and metafields.
- React to events through webhooks, for example when an order is created or a product changes.
- Add screens to the Shopify admin so staff can use custom tools without leaving Shopify.
- Extend the storefront through theme app extensions, adding blocks merchants can place in their theme.
- Customize certain business logic such as discounts, shipping and payment options, through Shopify Functions where supported.
If webhooks are new to you, our explainer on how webhooks let apps talk to each other covers the basics.
What a custom app cannot do
Shopify controls the platform, so some limits apply to every app:
- Checkout is restricted. Checkout changes go through approved extension points, and some options depend on your Shopify plan. You cannot rewrite checkout freely.
- API rate limits apply. Apps can only make a certain number of requests over time, so heavy jobs need batching or bulk operations.
- Platform rules come first. Shopify can change APIs, permissions and policies, and apps must adapt.
Knowing these limits early prevents expensive surprises. If a requirement depends on deep checkout changes, confirm it is possible before you plan around it.
Maintenance and API version upkeep
A custom app is software, and software needs care after launch.
- API versions: Shopify releases API versions on a regular schedule and retires older ones. Your app must be updated and tested before the version it uses is retired.
- Dependencies: frameworks and libraries need security updates.
- Hosting: apps with admin screens or webhooks run on servers or serverless platforms you pay for and monitor.
- Error monitoring: failed webhooks and API errors should alert someone, not vanish into logs.
- Change requests: your process will evolve, and the app will need to evolve with it.
Budget for this from the start. Good API design practices inside the app also make future changes cheaper and safer.
How to choose
Work through these questions in order:
- Is there a public app that covers most of the need well? Try it first.
- Is the need mainly moving data between systems? Consider an automation.
- Do staff need a custom interface inside Shopify, or does the logic need to run inside Shopify features such as discounts or theme blocks? That points to a custom app.
- Is the feature core to how you sell, and will it live for years? That justifies the ongoing upkeep.
Also count the cost of not building. If staff spend hours every week working around a gap, or several overlapping public apps each cover part of the need, a single focused custom app can simplify the store as well as add the feature.
Many stores end up with a mix: public apps for common needs, automations for data flows, and one focused custom app for the part that makes the business different.
How to brief a developer
A clear brief saves time and budget. Include:
- The problem: what happens today, who does it, and what goes wrong.
- The outcome: what should happen instead, described as user steps.
- Data involved: which Shopify objects and which other systems.
- Users and permissions: who uses it and what each person may do.
- Edge cases: refunds, partial shipments, bundles, multiple currencies or locations.
- Apps already installed that might overlap or conflict.
- Ownership: who will maintain the app and how updates are handled.
Our guide on how to write a software project brief includes a template you can adapt.
Frequently asked questions about a Shopify custom app
What is the difference between a Shopify custom app and a private app?
Private apps were Shopify’s older way of giving a single store API access, and they have been replaced by custom apps. Custom apps serve the same purpose with updated permissions and security, created either in the store admin or through Shopify’s Partner tools.
Can a Shopify custom app change the checkout?
Only within the limits Shopify allows. Checkout can be extended through approved extension points and Shopify Functions, and some options depend on your plan. Full control over checkout code is not available.
Do I need a custom app or just an automation?
If the goal is moving data or triggering actions between systems, an automation is often enough. Choose a custom app when staff need screens inside Shopify or when logic must run within Shopify features such as discounts, shipping rules or theme blocks.
Build only what your store needs
SiteWright Technologies builds focused Shopify custom apps, integrations and admin tools when they are justified, and we will point you to an existing app or automation when that is the smarter choice. See our full-stack development services, or get in touch to discuss the gap in your store.


